• 2,500 replies
    clayv
    Default Avatar
    Joined:

    Who's up for a revolutionary evolutionary ride? DAVE'S PICKS VOLUME 30: FILLMORE EAST, NEW YORK, NEW YORK 1/2/70 captures the Grateful Dead as they make their first foray from the experimental 60s into their early 70s acoustic Americana period. Yes, this one is a little bit country and a little bit (psychedelic) rock and roll.

    When the "Magnificent Seven" - Pigpen on percussion, T.C. on keys - first took the stage on 1/2/70, evidence was clear that the trip was about to take a turn. From their western wears to the twang in Jerry’s “broken-string blues,” it appeared they'd brought the Bakersfield sound to the Big Apple. They worked through much of what would become Workingman's Dead, stunning the crowd with laid-back numbers like "Uncle John's Band," "Casey Jones," and "Black Peter." Just the same, they satisfied 60s stalwarts with magical versions of "Dark Star," "St. Stephen," and "That's It For The Other One." Sonic alchemy, indeed!

    DAVE'S PICKS VOLUME 30: FILLMORE EAST, NEW YORK, ​New York 1/2/70 has been rounded out with a bit of 1/3/70 (the subscribers-only bonus disc features the bulk of 1/3/70). It was recorded by the great Owsley "Bear" Stanley and has been lovingly mastered to HDCD specs by Jeffrey Norman.

    DAVE'S PICKS VOLUME 30 is limited to 20,000 individually-numbered copies*.

    *Limited to 2 per order. Very limited quantity available.

Comments

sort by
Recent
Reset
  • Charlie3
    Joined:
    DaP 24 8/25/72

    After all the comments on the bass enhancement for DaP 24 I decided to revisit that one - I have to say that while the bass is certainly prominent at points, I don't really find it distracting and it is really a good show. I am running a straight 2 channel set up with some large floorstanding speakers and no sub-woofer, which may be a factor. There is generally something about a sub-woofer that is uncomfortable to my ears and the large floorstanding speakers have plenty of bass.

    JiminMD, nice summary of the road trips stuff. Have to say that the 12/28/79 show is one of my favorite releases from '79, and that 11/15/71 Austin show is also a highlight. Also dig the 3/31-4/1/88 release as I was at both of those shows, so that adds an extra element for me.

  • JimInMD
    Joined:
    Road Trips

    The series was ok.. but had some spectacular must haves.. As daverock mentioned. I bet Mr. Jack Straw has them ranked..

    Some really do kick some serious ass though, off the top of my head:

    - Valentines Day 68. A stunner. Don't forget to pick your lower jaw off the ground when the final chords of Midnight Hour dissipate or you will have a mouthful of dirt and/or gravel when the spell finally wears off.

    - 5/15/70 (on sale now). The best sounding 1970 acoustic stuff released thus far, and if that wasn't enough to seal the deal a couple awesome electric sets for good measure. (Well.. there are a few acoustic songs on Bears Choice, but these sound every bit as good).

    - 12/28/79 (the other Betty recorded 79 release that escaped the rapid fire synapse exchanges of the famed HendrixFreak)

    - 5/23&24/69 Big Rock Pow Wow. Wow is right! With every listen I like it more.

    - 6/16&18/74. As Daverock mentioned.. not to be missed. A jazz masterpiece and a Grateful Dead classic. Contains my personal favorite Eyes of the World (or at least the last one I listened to).

    - 11/21/73. Goodness! What a great show.. has a little 11/20 just because..

    - A summer and fall from '71. Not sure which I like the best.. Summer has a Dark Star>Bird Song and Fall has the Dark Star > El Paso > Dark Star.. a real Bobby Dazzler to be sure.

    - 6/9/76 (and a little from 6/12). I think it has Sixtus' fav. Eyes of the World and the only official release (so far) with Mission in the Rain.

    - Bonus discs.. some of these are to die for.

    Honorable Mentions include From Egypt with Love, Spectrum 82, Fall 77, well.. all the rest I guess.

    They did go overboard on the recycled packaging concept. Enclosing them in apparently rough-cut recycled brown grocery bags so dark brown on some the artwork could barely be seen. Not to fear though.. they also sourced and mixed in some barely used sandpaper to stiffen up the covers and retain that scratchy, fine grit freshness that delicate CD's just love! And apparently when they were shredding up the paper bags a few of the master reels cut all chopped up too. What else would explain chopping up some of the shows the way they did (thinking 74, summer 71, 79 and a few others).

    ________
    (sorry for the long post, for those under time restraints skip the jib/jab above and go directly to the executive summary below)
    ________

    I guess in summary.. under-rated.

  • Vguy72
    Joined:
    Give it just a minute....

    https://youtu.be/yXbpxNghcCw
    ....and it will blow away.
    Give it just a little minute, give it just a little minute, give it just little minute now!
    Love Phil's dolphin dye.

  • JimInMD
    Joined:
    Re: Rubber Bowl

    Kenny.. check your PM / EMail.

  • Charlie3
    Joined:
    Real Gone Feedback

    Thanks for the feedback on Road Trips Fillmore release. Before I ordered I had sent an email to Real Gone asking if the release was currently available, and the response stated: "We finally got it in. Retail release date remains unclear as a large portion of our stock is still missing. But you can order from our site now." Just in case anyone was interested.

  • hendrixfreak
    Joined:
    I'm still banking on....

    those two dead horses: '79 for DaP 31 and fall '72 for the box.

    A '79 for DaP 31 would seem to be the first since DiP 5 from 1996 (???!!!), at least according to my shelves. (Perhaps I have missed a release or two?)

    A fall '72 box would fly off the shelves while July 78 and PNW are still in stock.

    In 5 daze, we'll know about DaP 31 and in 23 daze we'll know the box.

    Yowzer! I sure hope I haven't jinxed anything...

  • estimated-eyes
    Joined:
    1978

    All the 1978 talk brought me out of the weeds. I have never been a completist with the Grateful Dead releases-- I have skipped plenty of releases over the years (box sets, Dicks Picks, Road Trips and skipped 4 Dave's Picks before doing subscription in year 3 and subsequent years). I have surely skipped some good ones-- especially some Dicks Picks that I should have in my collection, but hindsight.... If given the choice, I will almost always skip 1976 shows, the 1974 compilation releases, anything post-Brent, and most box sets because of cost and familial responsibilities.

    That said, a couple months back someone on here did a listing of releases by year. I am missing releases from almost all eras/years. I almost never skip a Pigpen release (kick myself for not getting the Kings Beach Bowl 1968 release). For every year sans Pig with a significant # of releases, I skipped some-- except for 1978. I found that I have every 1978 release they have put out.

    So, 1978 must be one of my favorite years. I think it goes back to my tape trading days. One of my first tapes was Winterland 10/22/78 and I soon got 7/8/78 (my 8th birthday) set 1 and encore. Both stellar shows and I can say that the Scarlet/Fire through Going Down the Road Feeling Bad on 10/22/78 is some of my very favorite Grateful Dead. I absolutely love the From Egypt With Love release. Not much to say about 7/8/78 that hasn't been said (I got KISS stuff at my 8th birthday party) other than I never had the second set and WOW.

    Dick's Picks 18 February 1978 is seared in my mind. Another top notch Scarlet/Fire, a long Samson (broken string extends the intro jam), top of the line Truckin' and a rockin' Other One with a screaming Jerry jam in the middle.

    I could go on and on (the Lazy Lightning/Supplication from DiP 25), but why 1978 for me? The sets are more predictable than 1977, many times the band seems to run out of steam after Drums even on official releases and Bobby was doing his experiments with slide guitar in front of 10,000 people nightly. Well, I think that I overlook the valleys and feel that the peaks are so significant that they truly elevate the rest of the show. I have skipped every box because of cost-- except July 1978. I couldn't pass that one up. And I love it-- and agree that the 'hidden' gem of the box is 7/1/78. They had to have melted some country and western faces that day. Just a blistering set in front of what was surely an interesting crowd.

    That said, there have been some weaker 1978 releases-- DaP 7 and the MacArthur Court come to mind. Both are overrated, in my opinion, but am happy to have them in the collection.

  • unkle sam
    Joined:
    Dave's 31

    will be announced on July 16th at 10 am.

  • Cousins Of The…
    Joined:
    Announcement

    I wonder... if they announce the new box during MUATM, does that mean there will be a pre-order email the following day? Like others mentioned, it seems odd that they would announce it first there...

  • Slow Dog Noodle
    Joined:
    Charlie

    I too pre-ordered that Road Trips (5-5-70) from Real Gone and got the e-mail around the original release date that it would be delayed. Mine showed up at the house (Chicago) this past Tuesday.

user picture
Default Avatar

Member for

6 years 9 months

Who's up for a revolutionary evolutionary ride? DAVE'S PICKS VOLUME 30: FILLMORE EAST, NEW YORK, NEW YORK 1/2/70 captures the Grateful Dead as they make their first foray from the experimental 60s into their early 70s acoustic Americana period. Yes, this one is a little bit country and a little bit (psychedelic) rock and roll.

When the "Magnificent Seven" - Pigpen on percussion, T.C. on keys - first took the stage on 1/2/70, evidence was clear that the trip was about to take a turn. From their western wears to the twang in Jerry’s “broken-string blues,” it appeared they'd brought the Bakersfield sound to the Big Apple. They worked through much of what would become Workingman's Dead, stunning the crowd with laid-back numbers like "Uncle John's Band," "Casey Jones," and "Black Peter." Just the same, they satisfied 60s stalwarts with magical versions of "Dark Star," "St. Stephen," and "That's It For The Other One." Sonic alchemy, indeed!

DAVE'S PICKS VOLUME 30: FILLMORE EAST, NEW YORK, ​New York 1/2/70 has been rounded out with a bit of 1/3/70 (the subscribers-only bonus disc features the bulk of 1/3/70). It was recorded by the great Owsley "Bear" Stanley and has been lovingly mastered to HDCD specs by Jeffrey Norman.

DAVE'S PICKS VOLUME 30 is limited to 20,000 individually-numbered copies*.

*Limited to 2 per order. Very limited quantity available.

user picture

Member for

13 years 6 months

In reply to by Sixtus_

Permalink

What are you guys smoking? 6/9&10/73? I have almost given up hope.. but with all this talk of the Brothers, that would be something.

user picture

Member for

10 years 10 months
Permalink

Sorry to hear the ABB bashing or, at least, the ennui. But to each his or her own.

I heard them live in June '71 over the radio during the closing of the Fillmore East, then got the FE double album. By 1972, my triumvirate were the GD, ABB and The Band. I find it interesting that that's still the case, 47 years later. I should add that I consider Jimi in a category by himself. And I'm a huge fan of the Three Kings (Albert, BB and Freddie) and their cousin, Buddy Guy. I won't type a complete list, but I'm also a major Roy Buchanan fan. But among rock bands, I had only three top choices, and lived in a time when I saw a shitload of all of them in their heyday or nearly so.

I caught ABB with the GD several times 6/9, 7/27, 7/28/73 and at Madison Square Garden in May '73, then again with the Derek/Warren lineup, ~1999-2009 (all at Red Rocks, almost always first 3 rows, center). A truly magnificent band of improvisers; the GD had nothing on them. Just two different flavors. Yes, the GD took more chances. But if you listen to the Duane era (two Jan '71 sets forthcoming this year, woo-hoo!), he pushed that band until it at times sound like Cream. I'm thinking of the official bootlegs series shows from '70 and '71.

Consider how psyched me and my buddies were when we heard of the Watkins Glen lineup! I'd already seen the GD 9-19-72 and 6-9-73 and the ABB in May '73. Our three best bands on the same stage! And a chance, finally, to see The Band. Great two days of music. (Plus mud, mescaline and blotter. No food to speak of.)

Then, incredibly, two days later, we caught the GD and The Band two nights at Roosevelt Stadium. (I caught The Band again on its final tour in '76, when they rocked the New York Palladium so hard that the balcony was in physical flux. I wondered at that time whether it had been designed for so much stress, but I didn't move from my standing position at my seat.)

All before turning 16. I caught the GD again that September '73. As a freshly minted 16 yr old, I already considered myself a GD veteran.

I guess the ABB and The Band are nearly as burned into my DNA as the GD.

Anyhow, like someone said, Butch said some nasty things. But forgiveness and understanding wipe away any ill will for me. I too have lamented that Mickey moved from really sensitive synchro'd drumming and percussion in his heyday to the "sneakers in a dryer" approach post-hiatus, which clodded up the sound, though I still enjoyed every Red Rocks show they ever played, plus Folsom Field, Telluride, etc. etc.

So I'm just raising the ABB flag over my pointy little head. If they're not your thang, so be it. But I've never seen a band quite like them and never will again. RIP Duane, Berry, Gregg, Butch.

user picture

Member for

7 years 7 months
Permalink

Personally, I love the ABB - but the ABB Fox Box recorded in Atlanta at the Fox Theatre, 9/24-26/2004 has the audience singing along with every classic song....ugh. Did this go down at later GD shows? Might as well breakout a Kumbaya encore! Then again, maybe I'm just an old grouchy bastard

All these years later and Bill Graham is still right - the GD were the only ones that did what they did. I think the ABB was close as anyone got. Maybe I've missed some one. I think most bands saw themselves as putting on a show and did the same show every night....charge on stage to great applause, hit all the notes, you know. It can be a great show, but you don't need to see it more than once. That's my 2 cents for today

Nice post. I’m not sure how the thread took the downward turn it did? Those three bands were my favorites also, and probably still are...I just always felt like the ABB didn’t need? no that’s not it?...it just sometimes seemed like their drummers played the exact same thing a lot, where B&M not so much? Anyway, just thought Butchs dig was ironic imho.
Never heard much negative from the Dead about the ABB, but unfortunately over the years can’t say the same about the Brothers. But hey, we all say stupid shit, and as I’ve said before, I try to like my musicians, atheletes, politicians, hell anyone who’s supposed to be professional, I try to like them for what they do more than who they are. Only cause that’s they way I want people to treat me at work.
Did not mean to, hopefully didn’t, diss the band at all. Like everyone else some years/bands were better than others, GD included.
Unfortunately, I didn’t get to see the ABB until the late seventies or early eighties. But it was the Warren/Woody years that first blew me away the most.(obviously not including the original line up albums ).
Man the Dead, The Brothers, and Santana were all having great resurgences during that late 80s, early 90s. Even saw the Brothers and Santana at Woodstock 94. The Band I first saw in the early 80s at the old Buffalo Train station, and yea no Robbie, but we didnt care. Saw them 84 in Rochester at the Summer party tent and it was one of the best concerts I’ve ever been to!!
Actually was fortunate to do Merch with them for some of the 90s shows, and ended up going to Chicago 95 at the last minute because of our Band connections/lamies etc. That’s what got us in, backstage, and we got to hang on the stage during the bands set. Everyone from the Dead except Jerry was up onstage watching them. Bob was standing right behind us. But of course, as soon as the Band was done they shagged our asses right off! Worked a couple tours with them in 96. They were all awesome, but from the very first time I met Rick Danko, man what a nice soul. Would always come over and say hi, sometimes right out to the booth, he'd walk over and shake your hand and say how great it was that you were there, just so nice.
If all you had on a desert island was some stuff from those three bands, I think you’d be 👍

I can’t imagine seeing the Glen show! I mean I’m sure the nasty conditions were ruff, but back when I was young, if I could have seen those three at once like that, phew!

user picture

Member for

17 years 5 months

In reply to by Oroborous

Permalink

....maybe Butch was drunk. I know me, and drunk me says/texts some stupid shit that makes next day sober me do a good ole fashioned facepalm.
St. Louis has, HAS to beat Beantown tonight otherwise it's all uphill from here....
ABB isn't even in my top 20 bands. And I only have one beer under my belt, so it's legit. Only saw them once. Rusted Root opened. Thought they were better.....don't throw stuff at me.
The thread took a downward turn Oro, because Butch pretty much said Bill the Drummer and Mickey suck. And the heads responded. Oh well. Second beer cracked. I better stfu. Anyone got a grilled cheese sandwich? Two bucks.
....edit. I've read a few band biographies, and there's usually a douchebag that screws it all up. I've never read anything of a Grateful Dead member being one. (maybe Phil after the fact. Maybe). Put that in your pipe and smoke the fuck out of it.
"Screaming and yelling he was licking his chops."

user picture

Member for

14 years 1 month
Permalink

First "rock" concert : Allman Bros. at Roosevelt Stadium in Jersey City, sometime around June 1974. Anybody there?
Dad drove us 9th graders. no weed no nuthin'. A good time was had by all, dad copped himself a couple beers, and we all made it home safely by 4AM. Dead and Co. coming up: Anyone going to the Hollywood Bowl? I'll be the guy with the tie dye and the white gotee...you can't miss me!!!!

user picture

Member for

12 years 2 months
Permalink

I bailed for quite a while because of the trivialness. In fairness, I contributed.

You are squabbling over a small handful of the greatest bands to ever walk the planet. The three in question are in my top five. I happen to include Traffic, but nobody ever cares. All are good in their own way. But, none of us would be here without the GD. I doubt the ABB or Band boards are this active.

For what it is worth, not right or wrong, I defer to folks who saw them live in the early years. In small venues. At their best.

But it still won't change my opinion.

Yeah, the Blues gotta pull this out. They let game 1 slip. To be honest, I am surprised they are tied.

For the info on The cost of the Europe 72 trunk

BTW Whoever brought up the suggestion for taking Dave's Pick 16 out for a spin....Thanks. A very nice China/Rider
and I love that version of TLEO.

user picture

Member for

10 years 3 months

In reply to by Oroborous

Permalink

I think that's spot on, what you said about liking people for what they do rather than what they are. When I was a teenager, I very much saw rock musicians as role models and style indicators. As the years passed, and the amount of life experience and books I read increased, it gradually dawned on me that great musicians might not be quite so admirable in any other respect. Interesting, for sure-but not exactly the fount of wisdom I once mistook them for when I was younger.

user picture

Member for

13 years 6 months

In reply to by daverock

Permalink

Had lots of fun seeing them over the years.. (and listening to them to this day). No regrets and my second favorite act to see live. Never got to see them with Duane or Berry, but did see them a lot over a long period of time thereafter. Perhaps my favorite show was in the later years, the Trucks Haynes duo was incredibly powerful. Phil opened and the Brothers closed. The loudest concert I have ever seen too.. my ears are still ringing.

Anyway.. I think I inadvertently started this whole thing off talking about Alligator and 1969. I bet there is a lot more love between the ABB and the GD than meets the eye, both with the musicians and the fan base.

Man were they good.

Speaking of 1969, they played a good portion of the immortal 11/8/69 Fillmore Auditorium yesterday on SiriusXM. I wish they could crisp up that recording just a little because the performance is smoldering embryonic Grateful Dead.

user picture

Member for

8 years 5 months
Permalink

Disclosure: I love, love, love the ABB. They were my "first love", if you will, although I listen to the Dead more these days.

Someone earlier referenced that famous Bill Graham quote, which is absolutely spot on. The Dead were the only ones that did what they did. Mixing folksy ballads, upbeat rockabilly, greasy blues, and spacey free jazz, sometimes all within one set? Fuhgeddaboutit.

The ABB reflect the converse of Bill's quote. They weren't the only ones that did what they did, but they were the best at what they did. They weren't trying to be as stylistically varied as the Dead; they just got up and shredded country-fried blues-rock like no one else before or since. They pretty much invented a genre of "Southern rock" and spawned many imitators.

I think its also important to note that rock history might be very different if Jerry and Phil were the ones who liked riding motorcycles.

I don't know shit about drumming, and don't have any insight as to which drumming tandem was more talented or accomplished. I heart them both.

In conclusion:
If one is going to pick a rock band to become obsessed with, and plan their life around what to listen to on what day, and anxiously await announcements of new releases on a message board . . . well obviously there is only one logical choice.

Captain and Tenille.

user picture

Member for

13 years 6 months

In reply to by Roguedeadguy

Permalink

Maan..that guy could plaaay the pioano (said in my best Trinidadian accent). [inside joke, I won't bore with details]

Muskrat Love > Dark Star > Whipping Post > Muskrat Love

Thanks for that.... a coffee chortling funny start to the day..

user picture

Member for

11 years 4 months

In reply to by JimInMD

Permalink

Hey dead net people , are you attending either show ? I saw a great deal on flights to Oakland and then back to Columbus from LA ($180 round trip !!) but I passed cause lack of funds for the other necessities, lol tickets !! but I am trying to collect the pins , band sells at each show. I can't make it out west, so I'm looking for a little help. If anyone is planning to pick up merchandise at the shows

user picture

Member for

17 years 6 months
Permalink

Will be appearing at Tommy’s Pizza in Browning.
I feel very fortunate to have seen the Allman Brothers twice, July 1995 in Arizona soon before that fateful day in August of that year. Dickey Betts and Allan Woody (as opposed to Woody Allen) were still in the band.
Just like I say to someone if they tell me they only saw the Grateful Dead once, very lucky.
The Captain and Tenille hook was an inside joke printed in the Glacier Reporter newspaper back in in 1980.

user picture

Member for

10 years 1 month

In reply to by JimInMD

Permalink

...aaaand for the record, I just wanted to say I wasn't dissing the ABB at all - I do enjoy them - in fact they were one of the first shows I saw up at UVM in 1991, good 'ole Patrick Gym. They ROCKED. Shortly thereafter, they put out that double live CD set 'An Evening with the Allman Brothers' which was, I believe, pulled from that same tour (could be mistaken). I always liked to think that Blue Sky that ended up on that CD was the one they played from UVM...whether it was or wasn't...I have no idea. It still makes for a more interesting listen though. But I loved that CD set, and I also had the Allman's CD box set way back in high school when it first came out - in fact this was my very first CD box (along with the Lex Zep box) and i LOVED it. I always also liked the release 'Wipe the Windows, Check the Gas' as well, it was a good live smattering with an outstanding Jessica on there. I always loved when Gregg went off on his pianer in there during that solo bit.

I also recall seeing them at the Beacon Theater in NYC, circa 1995 (?) over St. Patrick's Day. I EXPLICITLY recall during one song...and i forget which one - but they pulled off a ST. Stephen tease big time during one of the jams, and the place went nuts. So, there was a well-placed and respectful nod to the GD and everyone was happier for it.

Anyway - a lot of rambling here - but just wanted to get things straight on my love fore both bands, but still GD > ABB...and no hard feelings. I think in retrospect it just bums me out a little bit in consideration of the references to the bad feelings from band members toward other band members.

I mean, Can't we all just get along?

Sixtus

user picture

Member for

8 years 7 months
Permalink

... I’m long time fan of the ‘ABB’ as well. The recent ‘Bear’ recordings from the Fillmore East released this past year was a grateful & welcomed release! I don’t listen to them that often any more, I usually get in the mood around late summertime or when around the band would begin their ‘Beacon Run’ ... I remember when the band released their Atlanta Pop Festival performance on CD, man I played that album for months, morning noon & night lol I was captured not only by the bands performance but the “Primo Audio Quality!” I played it proudly and loud...
...I was Dickey Betts guitar roadie for awhile in my younger days! This was around the time he ran in trouble with the law for punching/fighting with his ‘Ol lady’ / wife at the time. We had a gig planed for the next day in Tappan, NY at the long gone ‘Kelly’s’ Pub, now renamed and different owner. We didn’t know if we would make it because of an arrest warrant but in the end the show went on! The Marshall Tucker band Opened for Dickey Betts and they gave the crowd a primo performance! I was in charge of Dickey Betts 6 different guitars, on stage left , just a few feet away from Dickey so I could hand off his different arsenal of instruments and Cold Beer! Very Cold Beer lol if it wasn’t cold enough Dickey would just toss them into the crowd, sometimes unopened and others with a swig missing lol ha ha lol, by mid-set my left was so numb & cold by dig’n deep inside what was a garbage can turned into a giant cooler filled with Budweiser/Coor’s beer & ICE! Lol...Grateful memories from those days. Vassar Clements also came aboard for a ‘Special Treat’ with his infamous fiddle playing, what a concert. I have a soundboard Of this concert in my collection. Haven’t listened to it in ages, I think it’s time to pull it out of hiding and give it a listening after all this talk of ABB , thank you All for your ABB posts, got my nose to itch :) 🙏❤️😎

user picture

Member for

17 years 6 months
Permalink

Super interesting history. Right on . Saw Marshall Tucker Band in Missoula back in mid 70s with original lineup . Caldwell brothers were formidable. Toy Caldwell played lead with-out a pick. Tommy Caldwell was a great bass player also. Both gone.
Awesome Allman Brothers story LMGirl!

I'll be kickin' it at the Bowl next Tuesday, Mbarilla. Though I don't typically saddle myself with merch (free mind, free hands), this will be my son's first Dead show, so I'm sure he'll want a shirt to sport afterward.

Hit me with a PM and let's chat about it. Maybe I can help you out.

user picture

Member for

10 years 4 months
Permalink

Thanks again for the cover artwork. I failed in The Other One mission. I too only took mental notes, and I was harried by the Dave's Picks 30 release. I can however, say without reservation, that the Other Ones from Europe 72 sound nothing like the pair on the new Dave's Picks 30 - but you already knew that ;-)

I think the only one I heard from the month of May was the Paris show on the 3rd. Oh wait, I also listened to Luxembourg. That one was really hot. Probably not news, but the one from Hundred Year Hall was a work of art. I usually have an easier time getting into them when they split them up into multiple parts, but that April 26th performance felt more like a Dark Star when it came to the improv parts.

I remember the opening show had a great one, split into a 19 minute first segment and an 8 minute second segment; the 8 minutes of part 2 is a rock and roll Fest all the way (crank it up) that goes right into Wharf Rat.

I remember the Dead in Denmark on 4/16 was short but awesome. There are two 3 minute segments with Me and My Uncle in between. The first segment is positively unique in that it's little more than Jerry playing the main theme softly while Pigpen adds some cool atmosphere with the B3 and Phil plugs away at the bass. Keith can also be heard playing notes here and there - always a pleasure. Nice transition into Me and My Uncle and then they go full boar Other One for another 3 minutes, where Bobby lays down the verses. The only explanation I can think of for the short performance is that the Truckin' had a 16 minute Jam after it. I guess on stage it was all The Other One to them.

I remember the New Castle show from April 11th is a really good one. The first 15 minutes was a combo of Other One theme music, up-tempo rockin improv, and a nice 5 minute taste of Feeling Groovy. Then they get a little Spacey and atonal, but not for long. Before you know it they're doing "Space Jazz"; I don't know how to explain it other than it sounds like half of them are still in atonal Space mode while the other half pick up a Jazz jam. If I had my musical wits about me, I'd probably say Billy and Phil went Jazz while the remainder stayed lost in Space. But it worked. It was like this gradual emergence from the real outer Space into the atmosphere - pretty bumpy at first, but eventually things smoothed out. Then they finished it off with The Other One reprise and concluding verses. The whole thing rounded out at..... I want to say 25 minutes, and then right into a superb Comes A Time.

And that was one more great thing about this tour. When you listen to it as a whole, yes, there is some repetition, but it's broken up nicely by other elements, like the rarely played Comes a Time, Lovelight, UJB, Dire Wolf, You Win Again, Caution, Sitting on Top, Rockin Pneumonia Hey Bo Diddley, Brown-Eyed Women, etc. And then the longer pieces are full of their own unique moments, which serves to mix it all up and keep things fresh. Great stuff. If Jim ever gets the wayback machine repaired, I'm going to wildly urge them to get St. Stephen, The Eleven, and Bird Song incorporated into a few shows.

user picture

Member for

8 years 7 months

In reply to by KeithFan2112

Permalink

...grateful post! I always enjoy reading your posts/reviews, thank you for sharing my friend!

user picture

Member for

7 years 10 months
Permalink

I dug the Allmans. The first show I saw of them was at Red Rocks with Dickey and Warren Haynes on guitar and Allen Woody on bass. Jaimoe and Butch, and of course, Gregg. The whole time I was pinching myself going, holy shit that's Gregg Allman and Dickey Betts up there.

To my ears Gregg was one of the finest blues singers ever and I'm not going to qualify it by saying "white." The man just oozed soul and I miss that gravelly delivery and world weariness. He was expertly cast as drug dealer Will Gaines in the movie Rush, as well, for those who haven't seen it.

The Derek Trucks/Warren Haynes era was killer, as well. Gregg gradually sobered up and put more energy into his performances. For anyone interested, Berry Oakley Jr., Devon Allman and Duane Betts are now fronting a band:

https://www.rollingstone.com/music/music-country/allman-betts-band-new-…

Last, I'll just say it's meaningless to compare the Dead with the Allmans. Much overlap, and much difference. All good if you ask me.

\m/

user picture

Member for

10 years 4 months
Permalink

Five to One baby, One in Five......

Oh by the way, I put out a trivia question last week when Five to One came up for discussion: What two guitar players used Robby Krieger's guitar solo on each of their own two original songs (hint - both guitar players came from groups who have sold millions of records). It was Ace Frehley of KISS and Mike McCready of Pearl Jam. Ace used it on the song She; McCready used it on Alive. Little bit of trivia I picked up over the years. The funny thing is that Mike McCready and Ace became friends many years later. As the story goes, Mike finally got up the nerve to tell Ace he stole his solo, to which Ace blurted, "Aack! Don't sweat it Curly, I lifted that one from Five to One.""

Wait a minute....hold the phone......as I'm writing this completely interesting Paul-is-dead-type of rock trivia piece, I'm realizing there are some odd coincidences at work here:

* The KISS song She is featured on KISS' album "Alive"
* The song Alive contains the lyric "she" - five times......Ladies & Gentlemen - we've come full circle.

user picture

Member for

13 years 6 months

In reply to by KeithFan2112

Permalink

I couldn't agree more, L.D.

Just a snipped from Wikipedia on the topic.. I love the just sing your guts out comment by older brother Duane.

Duane felt strongly his brother should be the vocalist of the new group (which effectively eliminated Wynans's position, as Gregg also played keyboards).[19] Gregg left Los Angeles and entered rehearsal on March 26, 1969, when the group was rehearsing Muddy Waters' "Trouble No More"[20] Although Gregg was initially intimidated by the musicians, Duane pressured his brother into "singing [his] guts out."[21]

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Allman_Brothers_Band

P.S. KF, who said the riding mower is broken? It's working fine, but it runs on mushroom dust and the mileage is not great.. it only gets a couple years per cap / stem. I think I broke out the original Avatar recently.. but I sort of prefer Peabody and Sherman. Perhaps I am dating myself.

user picture

Member for

9 years 3 months
Permalink

Strider 88, starting to think you're from the last best place based on your geographic references.

....into drumz->space, you can hear the crowd and band react to a stunning summer storm that rolled into Vegas and turned the Silver Bowl into a frenzied beast of electric energy....
https://archive.org/details/gd92-05-30.schoeps.ladner.10063.sbeok.shnf/…
This recording features it pretty well. Top five live Dead experiences for me. Heads all empty and i don't care indeed.

user picture

Member for

6 years 11 months
Permalink

I caught the Allman Brothers at the Beacon Theater in NYC a short while after Jerry shuffled off to parts unknown (the only time I've ever seen them live, unfortunately).

Though I was in a solidly altered state, I remember the highlight being a stellar "Blue Sky" interwoven with "Franklin's Tower".

It's a moment that's stuck with me all these years.

...some my favourite playing by Duane Allman occurred when he was a session player, before the Allman Brothers formed. The first cd of that excellent Skydog box set, where he is backing various soul singers, is a revelation. The version of Hey Jude by Wilson Picket is easily my favourite version of this song, and Duane's guitar solo at the end of the song, short though it is, must rank as one of his most exciting .

Thinking of the Dead-Allman's link-it seems likely that this version of Hey Jude was the one that inspired Pigpen to have a go - 3/1/69, again, comes to mind.

user picture

Member for

7 years 8 months
Permalink

Poor Dave L. Must have done the in the morning good ol fashion facepalm when he woke up the next day after seaside chat and read all over comments page"Morning dew ain't no filler". Whoops.

user picture

Member for

10 years 6 months
Permalink

Thanks for some fine "Other One" scrutiny Sixtus and Keithfan!

Since the 60's, always figured I was "HEARING" the Grateful Dead just fine. Thanks to you and all the other veteran heads, musicians, & assorted aficionados around here, I'm getting better at "LISTENING" to the Dead. Probably not the only one! Guess it IS possible to teach an old visual artist new tricks! Onward.

AND maybe Sixtus can be encouraged out on a limb to nominate his "Best Elusive T.O.O. Jam from Europe '72". All in good time, of course. No rush. . .

user picture

Member for

7 years 2 months
Permalink

KF (can I call you KF?), that is so cool, I never knew the She solo came from 5 to 1, or Alive for that matter. Check out my new Ace pic. Let me know if you need it.

user picture

Member for

7 years 8 months
Permalink

I also got caught up in other one broken up into multiple songs which is great but it's much more critical (if that's the word) to hear it as a single like Lux. And have a more concentrated critique. Good going KF.

user picture

Member for

10 years 4 months
Permalink

Well the title is a little bit misleading. I am probably least familiar with The Other One in all eras. I know few of them well enough to pick out of a crowd. When it comes to the holiday sleight of hand games that I play with my relatives and friends, I utilize cheap tricks - like honing in on sound quality to determine I'm listening to a two-track; that narrows down the field. But by and large, I have not mastered all there is to know about The Other One. Except for Dick's Picks 18 and The Closing Of Winterland - those I know note for note. There was a pretty good discussion on all of the great TOOs a few weeks ago.

Was there a best elusive Dark Star? Would love to hear that critique. I'm not sure what the criteria is, but I think it's just as it sounds, right? One that's been out there all along, dusty on top, so that it's widely overlooked, but shining with greatness underneath? I guess my vote would be Rockin' the Rhein, Part 2. My first Dark Star. There's a short spontaneous melody from Garcia in there that encapsulates The Grateful Dead for me in one or two short minutes.

Carlo, I think you're probably right about those one piece TOOs. I have a feeling the best magic is in those. Other One / E72 - The Final Frontier.

Mind Left Body - my friends call me KeithFan - you can call me John.

I was going to say that your Ace picture's too small, but it looks like you already changed it. I can tell you they were both Destroyer era :D

user picture

Member for

7 years 8 months
Permalink

I wouldn't touch the magnum opus with a ten foot pole. I don't think I am qualified to judge something so complex. I think Stephen hawking would be able to delve into The best Dark star like general relatively.

Introduction: FM radio, then cassettes/CD’s.

Live
8-25-90
$17.50, George Thorogood opened!

11-29-91
$12.50 and a can of food for the local food pantry. Little Feat opened!

8-25-96 (6 years to the date of my first ABB show).
$25.00, general admission at the Reno Hilton Amphitheater (stage, chain link fence, bleachers in the back, in the casino parking lot).

9-8-07 4:00 pm
$53.80, general admission in Piedmont Park (ABB opened for DMB, I went for ABB).

Had a great time at all of them, but didn’t compare to GOGD.

Also bought Bear’s Sonic Journals, CD and hi-def download.

user picture

Member for

10 years 1 month

In reply to by carlo13

Permalink

We all should tread carefully when tossing around Magnum Opus. However, in many contexts of the correct sort it's entirely appropriate.

There are certain things described as Magnum Opus. The Dark Tower, clearly one of them. Dark Star obviously falls into a slot Worthy. And as aforementioned, to drill down to a One And Only would be like trying to step into a black hole predicting where you'll end up on the other side. It's as Amorphis and Elusive yet melodically intrusive which ties you to whatever the best Dark Star is, and may be, at any given moment in time. Because it will change, it does change, yet it Remains The Same.

As our fellow friend JimmyInMD says, it's always the last one you heard that's the best one.

Sixtus

P.S. cheers to everyone here. This is fun stuff. And KeithFan, I think you're getting close to being everyone else's Uncle Gary. Exquisite contributions. And we're all among fellow Scholars.

....so, we have a peach tree on our backyard that is finally producing savory fruit after three years. Problem is....finches. Those little bastards hang out on the fence looking for opportunities. My wife wants to "Eat A Peach". So we put netting over it. That created another problem. One of our dogs wants to catch and eat said finches, proceeds to get his paws stuck in the netting, therefore creating gaps in it. Ugh. Reminded me of the recent ABB discussion.
Enjoying homegrown peaches shouldn't be this hard....
Regarding Dark Stars. The one they unleashed on Springfield, MA 3.28.73 (aka Scooby-Doo house Dave's 16), got quite Dark. So much so, that even though the lights were on in my living room, I still felt like I was In The Dark. Boo-Yah!!

Magnum Opus..

Quantum mechanics suggests that the mere act of studying a Dark Star.. listening to it and forming an opinion changes it's composition. Called the Dark Star Uncertainty Principle. So yes.. the last one listened to is always the best one ever performed. Simple physics.

In other words, I want what Sixtus is smoking (and I wholeheartedly agree).

user picture

Member for

17 years 6 months

In reply to by JimInMD

Permalink

....works for me! Wassup Dsup? Dirty Harry had a Magnum. And it was opus!

user picture

Member for

13 years 4 months
Permalink

I think the way to go about this release is to rearrange the songs in the correct order and listen to May 24th first and May 23rd second. May 24th is longer and has some very interesting moments (China>Eleven for example) and has the great Alligator>Drums>St Stephen>FeedBack>We Bid You Goodnight section but May 23rd is probably a tighter show and you get a great Dark Star. Also, if you listen to May 24th show first, you don't have to listen to two very long Lovelight's back to back...which almost reaches an hour of Lovelight. I love Pigpen but that's a lot of 'light!

user picture

Member for

10 years 4 months
Permalink

Mustin (and whomever) - when I file my songs digitally on my phone and computer, I always put the songs in the correct running order and put them in individual folders for each show. This presents a slight cosmetic issue when I view my playlist, as you end up with multiple albums with identical album artwork. That's no fun and it gets confusing when you're thumbing through your digital file system. I have created similar artwork, using very simple computer tools, to make different covers four different shows Within a set. For example Dick's Picks 33. For for example this Dave's Picks release, I just put all the January 3rd songs in the folder with the artwork from the bonus disc. What I'm getting at, is if anyone is interested in alternate artwork 4 multi-show sets let me know and I put them up on the link this weekend. This also may sound a little crazy, but I did not care for the May 1977 album cover art for either box set, so I just grabbed cool random artwork from the internet to use as album covers. Weird colored triangles and other computer-generated looking artwork reminds me of that hipgnosis company from the 70s that used to make a lot of record covers. They lost me sometime after Dark Side of the Moon. PM me if interested.

P.S. - I've re-engaged on the Europe 72 listening project on 5/24 at the Lyceum. Pigpen's last Lovelight. and IMHO, the best. The Allman influence is heavy during the instrumental jamming (which is a completely different beast in 1972), and at the 10-minute mark we here some of pigpen's most soulful improvisational lyrics, backed by the doot doot doo riff. This was one of the hooks that turns me into a Dead Head. It's only a minute long, but oh, what a minute it is.

P.P.S. - there's also one of the best me and my uncles you're ever going to hear on this May 24th show. Somebody put Jerry out, he's on fire.

user picture

Member for

9 years 8 months
Permalink

check your inbox

product sku
081227923761
Product Magento URL
https://store.dead.net/special-edition-shops/dave-s-picks-store/dave-s-picks-vol-30-1.html